Tag: quantum measurement problem

An illustration of a laboratory setup with Schrödinger's cat and an observer inside the lab, representing Wigner's Friend, with a second observer, Wigner, outside the lab.

Wigner’s Friend: Exploring the Paradoxes of Quantum Observation

andrew Leave a comment
Press Play to Listen to this Article about Wigner’s Friend.

Wigner’s Friend is a thought experiment in quantum mechanics that raises questions about the nature of observation and reality. It was proposed by the physicist Eugene Wigner in 1961 to illustrate the peculiarities of quantum mechanics and the problem of measurement. Here’s a detailed explanation of the thought experiment and its implications:

The Thought Experiment

Wigner’s Friend builds on the famous Schrödinger’s Cat thought experiment. Here’s how it goes:

  1. Schrödinger’s Cat Setup: Imagine a cat inside a sealed box with a radioactive atom, a Geiger counter, a vial of poison, and a hammer. If the Geiger counter detects radiation (because the atom decays), it triggers the hammer to break the vial, releasing the poison and killing the cat. According to quantum mechanics, the atom exists in a superposition of decayed and undecayed states until measured. Thus, the cat is simultaneously alive and dead until someone opens the box and observes it.
  2. Introducing Wigner’s Friend: Now, extend this scenario. Wigner’s friend is inside the lab, conducting the experiment with Schrödinger’s cat. From the friend’s perspective, the cat’s state becomes definite (alive or dead) when they open the box and observe it.
  3. Wigner’s Perspective: Wigner, however, is outside the lab and hasn’t made any observation yet. According to Wigner, until he observes his friend and the setup, the entire lab (including the friend) is in a superposition of states. His friend is in a superposition of having observed the cat alive and having observed it dead.

Implications and Questions

Wigner’s Friend raises several profound questions about quantum mechanics:

  1. Observer’s Role: It questions the role of the observer in the collapse of the quantum wavefunction. Who qualifies as an observer? Does observation by Wigner’s friend cause the wavefunction to collapse, or is Wigner’s observation necessary?
  2. Subjectivity of Observation: The experiment highlights the subjectivity of observation. From Wigner’s perspective, the friend and the cat are in a superposition until he observes them, while from the friend’s perspective, the cat’s state is definite upon their observation.
  3. Quantum Measurement Problem: It deepens the quantum measurement problem, which deals with how and why wavefunction collapse occurs during measurement. It suggests that there could be a hierarchy of observers, each affecting the state of the system in different ways.
  4. Relational Quantum Mechanics: The thought experiment aligns with interpretations like relational quantum mechanics, which suggests that the properties of quantum systems are relative to the observer.
  5. Many-Worlds Interpretation: Some interpret Wigner’s Friend using the Many-Worlds Interpretation, where each possible outcome of a quantum measurement actually occurs in a separate, branching universe.

Modern Considerations

In recent years, experimental advancements have allowed researchers to explore scenarios analogous to Wigner’s Friend, though not yet at the same complexity. These experiments continue to challenge and expand our understanding of quantum mechanics and the nature of reality.

Conclusion

Wigner’s Friend remains a pivotal thought experiment in quantum mechanics, highlighting the mysterious and counterintuitive nature of quantum measurement and observation. It serves as a tool for exploring and questioning the foundations of quantum theory and continues to inspire debates and investigations into the nature of reality.